Home

Advertisement

Customize
 
 
11 March 2009 @ 11:40 am
lying or editing?  
(Originally published at Pith and Vinegar: blog version.)

So it is time for me to fess up: not all of my personal anecdotes are 100% true. I mean, often they are, but sometimes I rearrange events or add a little character motivation or occasionally insert that line that I SHOULD have said but didn’t. I had someone earlier this week say that that made me a filthy liar and my reply was, “I’m not lying! I’m editing.”

And, to my mind, it’s true. I don’t fabricate entire events out of whole cloth, or turn people who zig into people who zag. But my innate tendency when I’m telling a story is to punch it up a bit. And I think I’m not alone in this, or at least I have David Sedaris on my side and that’s pretty good backup.

Really, so much of life now is about good self-PR. The whole social media thing? It’s all self-PR, which is part of the reason I so enjoy it. What is the “Jessica” brand? What does it believe in? What does it promote? What did it have for lunch? These are critical questions!

So does punching up the odd anecdote to make it more impactful* or more coherent or, yes, more flattering, constitute lying, or good old fashioned editing for your intended audience?

* “Impactful” is not strictly a word but it SHOULD BE.

____________________________

Down with Facebook! For all my Twittering and Digging and Blippring, I hate Facebook. It was kind of okay at first, and neat to catch up with old absentee friends. Then the interface got all cluttered with crap and I realized that I don’t actually care about that many people and my email box was hit with a plague of messages like, “That Person You Hated in High School wants you to join their Pirate Ninja Squad!” Despite the fact that some of my good friends still hang out there (Chris, dude, I am talking to you. Get a goddamned Twitter and save me some pain.), I refuse to participate.

 
 
( 1 comment — Post a new comment )
Captain Exposition[info]capnexposition on March 11th, 2009 10:22 pm (UTC)
Well, I sit on a funny sort of fence on this.As you know, I'm pretty emphatic in my belief in the value of honesty. On the OTHER hand, I believe that any story worth telling is worth telling well. I guess it comes down to what you market yourself and your writing as. If you declare yourself as a nonfiction, "slice of life" writer talking about the ups and downs of your daily life, you owe it to your audience to not spin tales out of whole cloth. That doesn't mean write in a dry, reporting "just the facts, ma'am" style, though. Any good recounting of what happens in your life can be spiced up with some evocative detail, or just some of your internal monologue as you're interacting with someone. The truth is never boring, when told well.
 
 

Advertisement

Customize